19 Comments

My grandfather got killed fighting to invading Iraqi army - 750 miles from their border, and 8 miles from his home. I need ‘progressives’ to tell me again who tried go commit genocide in that war, and who were the invaders. Swallowing the propaganda of the Free Palestine cult for decades doesn’t make them right; it makes them the useful idiots of Islamist terrorists.

Expand full comment

Can Palestinians be wrong? Yes, they have been making poor choices for decades and look where it’s gotten them

Expand full comment

You raise a number of very solid criticisms but I'm interested in why you didn't address the most important issue of all: The claim of indigineity. What is it that makes arabs living in the Gaza Strip a different ethnicity from arabs living outside of it? What makes arabs living on one side of the Jordan River a different ethnicity from those on the other side? When did this distinction occur? What defines it?

Expand full comment

Palestinians are profoundly wrong. And until they get right, their miserable conditions of life will not change.

Expand full comment

Of course.

Expand full comment

Great Work!

Thank you!

The next discussion could be about a complicated subject of Islam and Democracy. How could co exist? Maybe Islam needs a revision within.

Like Christian don’t burn “witches” and Israelites don’t “stone” people Like they used to.

Islam needs to be revised within to align with humanity and democracy

Thank you for your great article

Expand full comment

Thanks for making simplified a complicated topic

Expand full comment

How Columbia University employs this idiot douchebag is beyond me. Single-handedly, Khalidi makes Columbia a lesser institution than it could be. He’s a stain on academia and intellectualism

Expand full comment

You forgot one thing. Jews believe in God.

Expand full comment

Great work.

Expand full comment

The Arab Palestinians are most certainly wrong. Go and read the real history of the region.

Expand full comment

I read tome of excrement Khalidi wrote. Listened to it actually. I have nightmares of me trying to explain its presence in my Audible account. Know thy enemy… is what I say.

Expand full comment

Wrong would imply that they mean well and have not been engaging in the worst kind of propaganda for decades

https://marlowe1.substack.com/p/o-city-of-broken-dreams-the-stories

Expand full comment

Word!

Expand full comment

What an idiotic review... How badly it's aged... Are you happy watching your beloved zionist shithole becoming the pariah state it was always destined to be.

Expand full comment

Gosh, what a brilliant, well thought-out response.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I believe that the shit hole is Gaza. Particularly now that Israel has destroyed it. You can go on and on with your “anti-Zionist” rant, but here’s the emmes; Don’t start a fihght you can’t win. ‘Nuff said.

Expand full comment

The Arab who continuously cries out cringily & endlessly, "the ZiOnIStS hit me back" has been joined by the yemenis, the Lebanese, the Iranians, the bad syrians and of course the phallustinians.

From a jihadi army to a harem of blinded amputee eunuchs the IDF transformed hezbolla to ball less.

Qud is a sign of the thievery of Islam inappropriating the Temple mount in Jerusalem which may soon be utilized in accordance to the Torah laws now that the red heifers are within the borders of Israel as Hamas acknowledged a few months after starting the war during a ceasefire on a Jewish high holy day.

5785 is shaping up beautifully and watching the islamists implode is a tasty treat that gets better every day, look up the Shiite shrine in Iran's visitation with the pager boys in bandages crying out to Allah why have you forsaken me, it may give you the inspiration it gives me to stand behind Israel.

Expand full comment